Matt,
I would like to recommend Aircraft Insurance Agency in Waxahachie, TX. They're a broker, but consistently work to get me the best rates. Not only do they insure my "fleet", but they also now insure my employer.
They use well-known companies, like AIG and Phoenix to name a couple. We're working through a claim right now with them, and they've been fantastic. Others here on this forum are insured with them, and have received similar great service.
You may call Josh Jabour at (972) 227-8690, or via email at josh at airduncan dot com. It's a family owned business, and you can tell Josh that I sent you. It won't get me anything, it might even raise my rates, but at least it won't be a "cold" call.
At any rate, enjoy your new plane. Don't get frustrated by the lack of flying time you'll have during the winter. But, by spring, you will have soloed, and will be soaring above the beautiful PNW, getting ready for your PP checkride!!!
Congratulations again!
I can't recommend him highly enough. Great folks to deal with. They find the great rates, too.