Amy,
Good little airplane. Looked a lot like the Piper Hatchet, but without the problems; owners I know who have them seem to like them. Great visibility. Flew like a Beech, so very nice, solid handling. Instructors I've talked with about them also liked them a lot. Downside is that the fuel system is not as simple as the 150/152, so there is the risk of fuel mismanagement.
You did get some good advice - go fly one again and see if it meets your recollections and go fly a 150/150 and see what you think.
Warmest regards,
Rick