I found N3740J. In Gallipolis, OH. 5300 TT, 287 SMOH... Saw some pictures, looked good, called the guy up, the sheriff of Gallia County, OH.
At the same time, my bird was at that same airport getting some avionics work done. I may have been able to take a bunch of digipics for him had I known he was looking at it.
Like's been said before, ask the Club members for help: there's enough of us that someone might be close enough to act as a set of unbiased eyes for you.
