This is really what it boils down to.... plenty of indisputable disadvantages, one arguable advantage (speed...maybe maybe not) and only one true advantage (looks).
If you like the looks, anyhow.

I'm trying to decide whether I like the looks of NO spinner or a skullcap spinner. I like the utilitarian look.
What it comes down to is that there's no wrong way. Decide what is more important to you for your plane, and anyone who has a problem with your choice doesn't have to fly in your plane, right?