From one Matt to another.....welcome to the club!

All depends what you want to spend and what your use is likely to be..eg, VFR, IFR - do you want Fastback, Straight Tail, Pre or post 1970 - Standard, Commuter or Aerobat O-200 or o-320 equipped and so on
There are, in my opinion from 9K miles away, some quite interesting examples in the Club Classifieds, and for that matter on Barnstormers also......
So have a think about it, decide what you're really looking for and
then go looking - There are plenty of people here will to jump in and assist with commentary about issues or queries you might have along the way and/or on-site checks for you when the time comes also, I'm sure.....
Welcome again Matt